March 21 (Bloomberg) -- Many college funding
strategies go against the grain of conventional tax
planning because the tax moves may impair financial aid
prospects.
Income and assets in a child's name, for example, can
curtail chances for aid. Yet there are a number of tax
breaks and suggestions that can lower your tax bill
while making college more affordable.
Brian Greenberg, a Marlton, New Jersey-based
certified college planning specialist and certified
public accountant, said the ``tuition time bomb'' for
his daughter came when she was in eighth grade. It
compelled him to see college financing in a different
light.
``Good tax planning can often result in poor college
planning,'' Greenberg has found. ``Many CPAs recommend
shifting assets into a child's name for the lower tax
rate, but that may hurt their chances for financial
aid.''
Greenberg says some of the first questions to ask
have nothing to do with taxes or how much money you have
to spend on college. They include what school your child
is likely to go to and your prospect of receiving aid.
``Eligibility for aid is a function of where one
attends college,'' says Greenberg. ``Income over $75,000
may exclude many from inexpensive state schools, over
$125,000 may exclude you from mid-range private colleges
and over $200,000 from anywhere.''
Aid Available
Apply for aid no matter what your financial
circumstances because colleges offer merit scholarships
that aren't tied to financial need. Look for colleges
that favor grants over loans. Grants don't have to be
paid back and may be more generously awarded at private
institutions with large endowments.
``It may cost less to go to Columbia or Harvard
universities than smaller private colleges because their
endowments are larger,'' Greenberg says. ``Parents need
to be prudent shoppers when it comes to schools.''
If your chances for aid are good, who owns the assets
for college can make the difference in aid and taxes.
Greenberg says he had one client who was a single
mother whose son earned $5,000 for college. As the child
of a single parent, he should have qualified for a
generous aid package. Because his earnings were in his
name, he paid a penalty. Under federal guidelines, aid
is reduced by 50 cents on the dollar for student income
and 35 cents for student assets.
Assets in Parents' Names
For assets in parents' names, aid is cut only 5.6
percent. A student's income is ``taxed'' for financial
aid when it's above $2,400.
``The effective tax rate (including payroll taxes on
the money he earned) was 69 percent for this young
man,'' said Greenberg. ``His hard work and good graces
turned out sourly for him.''
That's why it's almost always better to place college
assets in parents' or grandparents' names if you will
qualify for aid. Just keep in mind that aid formulas can
be complicated. ``One can earn $60,000 and have $1
million in assets and won't receive any aid based upon
need.''
The U.S. tax code helps offset some tuition bills.
When it comes to the credits available, you must know if
you qualify to use them:
-- The tuition and fees deduction allows you to write
off up to $4,000 in education expenses. It's available
to married couples with $160,000 or less in adjusted
gross income and singles making less than $80,000.
Credits Worthwhile
-- The Hope credit covers only two years of qualified
tuition and fees up to $1,500. It can be used by married
couples with adjusted gross income under $105,000 and
singles earning $52,000.
-- Lifetime Learning Credit. With the same income
restrictions, this credit covers up to $2,000 in college
costs, or up to 20 percent of the first $10,000. You can
take either this credit or the Hope, but not both. Only
one credit per child is allowed.
Interest deductions allow you to write off up to
$2,500 in student loan interest annually. Income limits
are $130,000 for couples and $65,000 for singles.
Both the Hope and Lifetime credits also cover you,
your spouse or anyone you claim as a dependent. You
still have to meet the IRS's income guidelines, though.
While you may not qualify for these breaks, your
children may if they aren't claimed as dependents and
they have earned income.
Beyond the Breaks
If you don't qualify for any of those tax breaks,
don't despair. There are other routes to tax savings.
You can gift assets to your children to pay for
college. When giving appreciated securities, they will
probably pay 10 percent capital gains tax if the
securities were held a year or more, and they are in the
lowest federal income-tax brackets.
Here's the double-barreled tax break: Since your
children are in that low bracket, they also may qualify
for the Hope or Lifetime credits and the other
deductions if they are paying for college expenses from
their own assets. Again, they can't take the credits if
they are claimed as dependents.
If your children are receiving aid from their
grandparents, ask them to hold off until the children
have graduated. Once the money is in their name, the
children are subject to the 35 percent financial aid
penalty.
Other Strategies
When you integrate your tax and college planning, the
general rule is pay for college with as few after-tax
dollars as possible.
Keep in mind that you can also use money in Roth IRAs
for college funding and not be subject to an early
withdrawal penalty. Since that money is in your name, it
won't hurt your children's aid prospects.
While the complexity and unfairness of taxes and
college planning may be stressful, it pays to get help.
Consult a college or tax planner on how to finance
education long before the university sends you the bills
-- preferably before your child is in middle school.
If you develop a plan that sets enough money aside
for college while lowering your tax bill, it should be
academic from there.
To contact the writer of this column:
John F. Wasik in Chicago at jwasik@bloomberg.net.